İnceleme toplayıcı [[Metacritic]]'e göre oyun "genel olarak olumlu" eleştiriler aldı.
{{Video oyunu incelemeleri|başlık=|altyazı=|EGM={{rating|4|5}}<ref name="EGMReview">{{CiteWeb webkaynağı|url=https://egmnow.com/tell-me-why-review/|titlebaşlık=Tell Me Why review|datetarih=August27 27,Ağustos 2020}}</ref>|GI=7.75/10<ref name="GIReview">{{CiteWeb webkaynağı|url=https://www.gameinformer.com/review/tell-me-why/tell-me-why-review-too-much-left-unanswered|titlebaşlık=Tell Me Why Review – Too Much Left Unanswered|firstad=Kimberley|lastsoyadı=Wallace|website=Game Informer}}</ref>|GameRev={{rating|2.5|5}}<ref name="GameRevReview">https://www.gamerevolution.com/review/657356-tell-me-why-review-dontnod-pc-xbox-one</ref>|GRadar={{Rating|5|5}}<!---The first episode was rated 4/5, the whole game's rating is 5 stars!--><ref name="GRadarReview">{{CiteWeb webkaynağı|lastsoyadı=Henley|firstad=Stacey|titlebaşlık=Tell Me Why review: "The new gold standard for trans characters in games"|url=https://www.gamesradar.com/tell-me-why-review/|access-dateerişimtarihi=27 Ağustos 2020-08-27|website=GamesRadar+|url-status=live|datetarih=August27 27,Ağustos 2020}}</ref>|IGN=7/10<ref name="IGNReview">{{CiteWeb webkaynağı|url=https://www.ign.com/articles/tell-me-why-review|titlebaşlık=Tell Me Why Review|accessdateerişimtarihi=August27 27,Ağustos 2020|website=IGN|firstad=Janet|lastsoyadı=Garcia|datetarih=August27 27,Ağustos 2020}}</ref>|MC=PC: 78/100<ref name="MCPC">{{CiteWeb webkaynağı|url=https://www.metacritic.com/game/pc/tell-me-why|titlebaşlık=Tell Me Why for PC Reviews |accessdateerişimtarihi=August30 30,Ağustos 2020|website=Metacritic|url-status=live|archive-urlarşivurl=|archive-datearşivtarihi=}}</ref><br>XONE: 79/100<ref name="MCXONE">{{CiteWeb webkaynağı|url=https://www.metacritic.com/game/xbox-one/tell-me-why|titlebaşlık=Tell Me Why for Xbox One Reviews |accessdateerişimtarihi=August30 30,Ağustos 2020|website=Metacritic|url-status=live|archive-urlarşivurl=|archive-datearşivtarihi=}}</ref>|SN=9/10<ref name="SNReview">{{CiteWeb webkaynağı|url=https://www.shacknews.com/article/119997/tell-me-why-review-fairy-tale-twin-magic|titlebaşlık=Tell Me Why review: Fairy tale twin magic|accessdateerişimtarihi=August 27, Ağustos 2020|datetarih=August 27, Ağustos 2020|website=Shacknews|firstad=Ozzie|lastsoyadı=Mejia}}</ref>}}
