*[[Allmusic]] {{rating|4.5|5}} <ref name="AMG">{{citeWeb webkaynağı |ilk=Johnny |son=Loftus |başlık=Mezmerize: System of a Down |url={{Allmusic|class=album|id=r737666/review|pure_url=yes}} |yayımcı=[[Allmusic]] |erişimtarihi=30.11.2009}}</ref>
*''[[Entertainment Weekly]]'' A− <ref>{{citeHaber newskaynağı |ad=Tom |soyadı=Sinclair |başlık=Mezmerize (2005): System of a Down |url=http://www.ew.com/ew/article/0,,1060789,00.html |yayıncı=[[Entertainment Weekly]] |erişimtarihi=30.11.2009 |tarih=16.05.2005}}</ref>
*[[PopMatters]] 9/10<ref>{{citeWeb webkaynağı |ilk=Adrien |son=Begrand |başlık=System Of A Down: Mezmerize |url=http://www.popmatters.com/music/reviews/s/systemofadown-mesmerize.shtml |yayımcı=[[PopMatters]] |erişimtarihi=30.11.2009}}</ref>
*[[Robert Christgau]] {{Rating|1|1}}<ref>{{citeWeb kaynağı web|url=http://robertchristgau.com/get_artist.php?name=system+of+a+down|başlık=CG: system of a down|yayımcı=RobertChristgau.com|erişimtarihi=22.03.2012}}</ref>
*''[[Rolling Stone]]'' {{rating|3.5|5}}<ref>{{citeWeb webkaynağı |ilk=David |son=Fricke |başlık=System of a Down: Mezmerize |url=http://www.rollingstone.com/artists/systemofadown/albums/album/7309436/review/7313411/mezmerize |yayımcı=[[Rolling Stone]] |erişimtarihi=29.01.2012 |arşivurl=http://web.archive.org/web/20070428001633/http://www.rollingstone.com/artists/systemofadown/albums/album/7309436/review/7313411/mezmerize |arşivtarihi=28.04.2007}}</ref>
*[[Stylus Magazine|Stylus]] B− <ref>{{citeWeb webkaynağı |ilk=Rollie |son=Pemberton |başlık=System Of A Down: Mezmerize |url=http://www.stylusmagazine.com/reviews/system-of-a-down/mezmerize.htm |yayımcı=[[Stylus Magazine]] |erişimtarihi=30.11.2009}}</ref>
*''[[Kerrang!]]'' {{rating|5|5}}
*[[Pitchfork Media]] 7.1/10.0<ref>{{citeWeb webkaynağı |url=http://pitchfork.com/reviews/albums/11839-mezmerize-hypnotize |başlık=System of a Down: Mezmerize / Hypnotize |yayımcı=[[Pitchfork Media]] |erişimtarihi=29.01.2012}}</ref>
